Monday, May 16, 2005

Liberals go a fearmongering, again

According to MP Joe Volpe, Minister of Immigration, if the Liberal government falls 100,000 to 200,000 of 'undocumented workers' will lose the opportunity to become legal immigrants and thousands of potential employers will lose out on the skills these 'undocumented workers' offer reports the Toronto Star (registration required).
A plan to legalize thousands of undocumented workers in Canada's underground economy would be in jeopardy if the Liberal minority government falls as a result of a non-confidence vote on Thursday, says Immigration Minister Joe Volpe. The Toronto MP has already signed off on a final draft of the long-anticipated "regularization" plan, which is now "in the queue" for the cabinet's feedback and approval — provided there isn't an election call.

The issue leaves in limbo many of the 100,000 to 200,000 undocumented workers living under the radar in Canada, as well as employers facing shortages of the skills some of them bring. "Here we're now at the 11th hour because the opposition is trying its best to create a controversial environment, and we are faced with a situation where all this hard work may go asunder," Volpe told the Toronto Star from Ottawa. "We're bringing things closer to a point where some decisions could be made."

Juan Sierra, a construction-union outreach worker, said he has fielded calls from hundreds of undocumented construction workers since Conservative leader Stephen Harper vowed publicly to bring down the Liberal government in mid-April.
They're worried the plan to legalize their status in Canada will go down, too.
"They are really freaked out by the prospect," said Sierra, of the Labourers' International Union of North America. "Their hopes were so high because Volpe has promised that this is a priority for the government. If nothing happens, their hopes would be destroyed totally."

According to Vilma Filici, president of the Canadian Hispanic Congress, part of a community coalition that has been negotiating with the government, the two sides had a consensus on the basic plan. "We are very concerned that this (plan) won't happen if there is a vote of non-confidence by the opposition in the parliament," Filici said. "With a new government, we'd be back to the drawing board again and start from scratch."
Filici fears a Conservative government could dump the plan as, he says, the Tories tend to view undocumented workers more as security risks than as potentially valuable contributors to Canadian society.

I first heard the term 'undocumented worker' used on US news broadcasts rather than the more accurate and easily understood term 'illegal alien'. I had not thought this madness had infected mainstream Canadian society. My bad, I should have known that the Liberals would be the first to adopt this doublespeak and flog this term into the mainstream.

I will admit that the term 'undocumented worker' grates on my nerves and I possess very little sympathy towards the plight of illegal aliens. Nor do I view them as the kind of citizens that have much to contribute to Canadian society. Canadians have one of the most generous refugee systems in the world. There are sound reasons why the Department of Immigration has quotas or caps on who can legally immigrate and who cannot. There are many laws on the books in Canada that I fundamentally disagree with, and yet, I conduct my affairs within the parameters of those laws. I fail to see how one can be a desirable immigrant by flaunting the laws of the land when it is in one’s financial interest to do so though I can understand the appeal of this issue for a Liberal MP.

I am very pro-immigration providing that those seeking entrance into this country are willing to follow all the laws of this land in the same way I do so but I draw the line on those who cherry pick which rules they will follow and when. If the ability to cherry pick which laws one will chose to follow is a desirable trait in a potential immigrant; why draw the line on those who refuse to recognize the right of Canada to decide issues of sovereignty? Let’s make convicted drug traffickers or murderers eligible as well.

Read the rest of the Toronto Star article as it becomes more outrageous as one reads on. The Toronto Star profiles the plight of an illegal alien couple who clear approximately $6,000 cash a month and in their favour have to pay for medical care out of their own pocket. Of course, no one makes the case that because they do not pay those cripplingly income taxes the rest of us are subjected to which allows for the operation and very existence of those hospitals, roads, schools and municipal services that they should not benefit from those services in the first place.

Furthermore, I do not become more sympathic to their plight because their lack of status makes them ineligible for EI; the ability to collect EI should not be considered a selling point to have legal status granted on illegal aliens. However, it does makes this documented tax payer want to burn my passport and SIN card so I can go work as a "undocumented' chambermaid.

9 comments:

AWGB said...

Maybe I should become an undocumented worker. That's not bad money at all. Way more than I currently make.

Anonymous said...

Six thousand a month is significantly more than my wife and I make (after taxes, of course). And as many people wanting to have home renovations discover, cash is the preferred method of transaction for avoiding further tax attention. In some cases, the cash discount can approach 30%, which boosts that couple's actual income substantially.

Sometimes it's tough to work up a good sympathy for people . . .

AWGB said...

Maybe it was a bad example by the Star.

Oh no, they have to pay health care out-of-pocket.... just like they did back home.


I figure that 12% of that would, on average, go towards health care if they spread it evenly. The only trouble is, that as an individual, you can't spread the risk through an HMO or public health care - if your kid got cancer, then you'd be hooped.

But still, 6 g's is a lot of money.

When you come out of the underground economy, you gotta pay taxes - how many of those people want to pay taxes? They can still use highways, public transit and the like without having to pay taxes.

If it helps to track potentially harmful people, then why not "document" them? It could put the sweatshop owners in BC out of business because the payroll taxes and minimum wage requirements would kill them. It could be a good thing.

So yeah, document them, but leave the fearmongering out of it.

K. Shoshana said...

The problem lies in that there is a legal way of immigrating without flaunting the laws of the land. A co-worker and her husband saved their money for five years and then started the legal process to immigrant. We all make choices and sacrifices in order to live out our life choices. It is absurd to reward illegal aliens for flaunting the law of the land, not to mention the great slap in the face for people like my co-worker and her husband. You only get one chance to make a first impression, and if you start your residence in Canada by willfully flaunting the law it does not bode well for your citizenship

james said...

It certainly shows a lack of value we have in our own citizenship. We just take it for granted and feel that we are better people for being so magnanomous to let everyone who wants in, have a set of keys even though they haven't even earned it. Why would they need to earn something that is valueless?

K. Shoshana said...

You are absolutely right, I do not know what it is to be an illegal alien and wherever I have chosen to live I have done so legally with respect to the laws of the land I was residing in. Let us be perfectly clear on that. My husband was an immigrant and his family choose to immigrate to Canada. They did not come here like a thief in the night but instead chose to follow the laws of the land. My co-worker and her family underwent many hardships to come to Canada but she did so legally. Your presence here is a slap in the face for everyone who followed the laws of Canada and to those who currently live here.

Anonymous said...

There is a strong possibility that many of you who are spouting off about illegals are living here legally because your fore parents made the trek and lived here illegally.

Lighten up! I think it's more about fear. People will always be leaving from country to country seeking opportunities.

Check your background. You may be surprised!

Selah!

K. Shoshana said...

I know exactly who, when and how my ancestors and my late husband's family got here, and the trek might not have been just but it was always very legal which I presume is probably more than can be said of yours.

But more importantly you are missing the point which has nothing to do with fear - save your pop psychology for your Mother, maybe she will be impressed because I am not. No one is suggesting that legal immigration be ended to Canada, and I no problem if anyone wants to come from any other country in the world to participate and contribute to my Country but I am not interested in populating Canada with those who are criminal by nature, intention or habit. Criminality in the citizenship tends to disintegrate the society -not enrich it.

Anonymous said...

If you plan to come to Canada as a tourist, student or as an immigrant, I invite you to visit our website to get information about services we provide to people coming to Canada:

Website: http://www.vamosacanada.com/index_e.htm

We offer the following services:

A) Immigration Services:

1. Case evaluation and recommendations
2. Application forms
3. Visa case processing for the following categories: permanent residence, temporary residence (work permits/NAFTA/SWAP/GATS), citizenship, sponsorships, change of status, etc.
4. AuPair/Nanny/Caregiver Program (screening and family matching)
5. Translations from Spanish, Portuguese and Italian to English

B) Services for new immigrants (people with permanent resident status who will be moving to Canada soon):

1. Airport pickup (Toronto and Montreal)
2. Temporary accomodations *
3. Apartment search
4. Resume adaptation
5. Transportation from temporary lodging to apartment
6. SIN (Social Insurance Number) and Health Card obtention
7. Driver license obtention
8. Bank Account
9. City map and info (Toronto and Montreal)
10. Kids school registration
11. Temporary Health Insurance (IHIP)
12. 3rd party Accounting Services (I.e., Tax return)
13. Retirement (RRSP) and Education Savings (RESP) plan consultation
14. Auto insurance
15. Airplane tickets
16. Car rental
17. Help buying a car
18. Translations from Spanish, Portuguese and Italian to English

C) Services for students:

1. Airport pickup (Toronto only)
2. Homestay *
3. Bank Account
4. School registration in many Canadian cities
5. Competitive prices and promotions in the best schools
6. English, French, TOEFL, TESL, IELTS and English for business courses
7. Acting and Film, Cooking courses
8. City map and info (Toronto and Montreal)
9. Summer and winter camps
10. Airplane tickets (with student discounts)
11. Transportation to schools (Toronto only, from our homestay)
12. Tours (provided by a 3rd party)
13. Student visa processing and Visa extensions
14. Translations from Spanish, Portuguese and Italian to English

D) Services for tourists:

1. Airport pickup (Toronto and Montreal)
2. Temporary accomodations *
3. City map and info (Toronto and Montreal)
4. Airplane tickets (with student discounts)
5. Tours (provided by a 3rd party)
6. Tourist visa processing and Visa extensions
7. Translations from Spanish, Portuguese and Italian to English

* Temporary accomodation / homestay is optionally provided by Vamos a Canada, subject to availability and at an additional cost.

These are most of the services we offer. If you have special needs let us know what it is and we will try to acommodate it.

I hope this helps. If you have any question or comment please let me know.



Regards,


Vamos a Canada
info@vamosacanada.com